Hillier Smith Critic — Edit critic — YouTube retention school
HillierSmithCritic is a second pair of eyes before you upload. It names the exact crime in your cut, quotes the timecode, and hands you the fix — without editing anything itself.
Adding an agent takes you to Eddie. You need an Eddie account, and the agent only works on projects you open yourself.
What Hillier Smith Critic does
- 01
Reviews your cut the way Hayden Hillier-Smith roasts one — trained on his Editing Mistakes and Editing Secrets catalog
- 02
Names the exact crime (unmotivated cut, over-trim, timid sound design) with the timecode and the fix
- 03
Never touches your timeline — pure coaching, dry British wit included
The method
Hook-first retention editing from Logan Paul's long-time editor: motivated cuts, rhythm, J-cuts, stylistic sound design, murder-your-darlings selects.
Who it's for
YouTubers and editors who want a brutal-but-friendly second pair of eyes before they upload.
What it knows
HillierSmithCritic carries one skill: a body of craft knowledge it loads when the task calls for it, rather than carrying it in every reply.
Hayden Hillier-Smith — editing methodology
When editing video content for maximum audience engagement, emotional impact, and effective storytelling, especially for YouTube and commercial applications.
What it can touch in your project
Never changes your timeline
HillierSmithCritic does not change your timeline. It reads, watches and comments. Every fix is yours to apply.
- Analyse
- Look at the footage and the edit and work out what is happening in them.
- Comment
- Leave notes on your timeline at the moments they refer to.
- Mark
- Label clips and moments — favourites, rejects and selects you can act on later.
- Play back
- Move the playhead so you can watch the moment being discussed.
- Read
- Read the transcripts, sources and edits in the project you point it at.
How to use Hillier Smith Critic in Eddie
- 01Add the agent to your workspace with the button above.
- 02Open the project you want it to work on.
- 03Type
@HillierSmithCriticin the prompt box and ask your question in the same message. - 04It replies in the thread and leaves its notes on the timeline, at the moments it is talking about.
Critic: Critics review and do not build. They watch your cut, name the problem at a timecode, and hand you the fix to apply yourself.
Agents like Hillier Smith Critic
Other agents for youtube & creator video, and others that work as a critic.
StrategistMr
Video strategist, ideas, packaging, retentionYouTube & creator videoBeast Method 11 runs
CriticBigelow
Tension critic, real time and consequenceDirecting & performancePressure
CriticBong
Tone & structure critic, genre tightropeStory & scriptGenre Mixer
CriticDeakins
Cinematography critic, light & frameCinematographyEye
CriticDel
Fable and design critic, motif, colour, creatureFilm craftToro Fable
CriticFincher
Directing critic, precision & performanceDirecting & performancePrecision
What an agent is
A named editor you add to your Eddie workspace. Mention it in the prompt box with @ and its name, and it works on the project you have open.

Try Hillier Smith Critic on your own footage
Add it once and it stays in your workspace, ready to mention on any project.