What the episode covers
His position on AI is specific. He uses it as an intern, admin and research assistant and wants it to give him a head start after a shoot, but he still expects to watch the footage, because the behaviour and nuance in it are hard for AI to read. In his USC class he banned generative AI and allowed tools for drafting and research. In documentary generally, he says, generated material can be acceptable only if the film is open with its audience about using it.
Key moments
- 01
Silence as the main character
In Pursuit of Silence opens with about four and a half minutes of silence. Shen says that was the film's way of teaching the audience its language, and that the surround mix was designed at Skywalker Sound.
Read this part of the transcript - 02
How the soundtrack was built
Most of the film's sound was recorded on location, sometimes with a holophone, a five-microphone array. Production sound is the foundation; sound designers then build environments and atmospheres around it, especially for a surround mix.
Read this part of the transcript - 03
Why the anechoic chamber scene has no sound at all
The chamber at Orfield Labs was 13 dB below the threshold of human hearing, so even a clean recording carried the hiss of the recorder itself (he believes it was a Sound Devices 633). The team removed the audio entirely. Shen also lay in the chamber for 40 minutes in the dark and describes the inner chatter that took him 15 to 20 minutes to quiet.
Read this part of the transcript - 04
From metal bands to a film about silence
Shen played in metal bands growing up and only learned how bad his tinnitus was inside the chamber. Music was his first way of speaking to the world; film became a second language for the questions he was working through.
Read this part of the transcript - 05
Making films instead of chasing advice
He watches a handful of documentaries a year. He remembers meeting the same people at LA networking events year after year, still shopping the same script, and tells students that their originality depends on what they take in, so he draws on other art forms rather than recent films.
Read this part of the transcript - 06
What a well-run festival gives a film
Shen compares festivals that cultivate an audience, where screenings sell out and people ask good questions, with festivals that fill a program to win sponsors. To make screenings an event, musicians performed John Cage's 4'33" before them, and at SXSW ticket holders got front-of-line access to an artist's silent room installation.
Read this part of the transcript - 07
A film 600 years in the making
With Brandon Vedder he is making As Slow as Possible, about an organ performance in Halberstadt, Germany, that began in 2001 and is due to end in 2640. They hope later generations will make further installments, with the last premiering when the performance ends. The two are also making a film about the avant-garde filmmakers Nathaniel Dorsky and Jerome Hiler.
Read this part of the transcript - 08
AI as an intern, and the line on generative AI
Shen calls AI the best intern and research assistant he could have, and says it has freed his time for creative work. He still watches his footage. In his class he allowed AI for drafting and research but not generative AI, and he argues that generated material in a documentary needs transparency, because audiences expect a claim to truth.
Read this part of the transcript
In Patrick's words
“There's a time and place for metal and there's a time and place for silence, you know, like we need both.”
On being a former metal musician who made a film about silence “I think at the end of the day, you still have to kind of watch the footage.”
On what AI can and can't do for a long-form documentary “Truth is kind of baked into the contract, right?”
On why documentary audiences expect something true “People should consider that AI is not the boogeyman that many make it out to be and consider it as part of our toolkit.”
On AI used ethically and transparently “Your originality as a filmmaker is directly linked to the things that you're consuming, the people that are influencing you.”
On what he tells students about influences
Short clips from the episode
Best intern
Why AI appeals to documentary filmmakers with small teams and small budgets, and the jobs Shen gives it.
On YouTube soonFestival curation
What separates a festival that builds its audience from one that just fills a program.
On YouTube soonInspiration
Why he watches few films, and why making the work beats waiting to be inspired.
On YouTube soonTruth contract
His classroom rule on generative AI, and the claim to truth every documentary makes.
On YouTube soon
AFTER THE SHOOT
A first pass on the footage, not a replacement for watching it.
Shen wants selects pulled after a shoot, even from the b-roll, and still expects to watch the footage himself. Eddie's b-roll logging tags every shot by subject and movement, and a separate analysis marks moments the transcript can't carry, such as a voice breaking, a long pause or a look away.
Full transcript
Transcribed from the episode video and lightly cleaned: filler words (um, uh) and repeated words are removed and misheard names are corrected. Two lines of the opening introduction are condensed; square brackets mark the changed words. Quotes on this page are taken from this transcript.
Read the transcript 7,370 words
Hey guys, this is actually the very first episode of the Rough Cut podcast. We've had the Substack going on for nearly a well in about 11 days. It's been it'll be a year and we've decided to […] extend a lot of the written deep dives into other filmmakers and workflows that we've been doing for the past year [into a podcast]. So, we thought what better way to kick that off with a filmmaker that actually has already been, you know, subscribed to our email list and Substack. So, we have Patrick Shen with us today. Patrick Shen is an amazing documentary filmmaker. Patrick, if you want to, I guess, extend a bit more of the intro in terms of letting the viewers know a little bit more about what you do, what you've done, and you know, what you're about.
Yeah. Yeah, sure. Thanks for having me on the podcast, by the way. Huge fan of Eddie AI. Super intrigued with the platform and the Rough Cut newsletter is fantastic. Anyway, yeah, so I'm a documentary filmmaker primarily. I've dabbled in fiction. Also dabble in photography and some other things but primarily a non-fiction filmmaker and I primarily do non-fiction films of the kind of like theatrical kind of cinematic variety I guess you could say. I don't do the reality TV stuff. I don't do kind of like the TV documentaries. I typically do the sort of feature length you know deep dive into certain subjects. I've been doing that for about maybe 25ish years or so now.
I also do a fair amount of teaching on the side. I teach documentary at USC, although furloughed this semester due to budget cuts. And I've taught for Sundance Collab, Film Independent, and a number of other film organizations. I always tell people my films tend to lean towards the existential. I use my films as a way to kind of work out certain kind of existential curiosities and journeys that I happen to be on. I figure if they have some kind of like meaning and purpose to my own life that it'll reach other people as well. So that's what I'm basically about in a nutshell.
Nice. Yeah. And I I think I definitely felt that when I was watching your work. It definitely felt very existential in the sense that I think there was actually an interview that I saw where you said there was a filmmaker that you had as an inspiration and he would say that something along the lines of a film should be of something rather than just about something. And just from watching In Pursuit of Silence I could immediately you know feel it like the sound when I did hear sounds it almost felt hyper real. I didn't even feel like normal because we had so much so many bouts of silence in the film.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, if you get a chance to watch it in I don't know if you did when you watched it in a surround sound setting we had these just crazy talented magicians at Skywalker Sound designed design the sound the immersive sound experience of that film. So it's really something special to hear in and surround. But yeah, we said from the beginning like silence is it that's the driving element of this film. It's the it's the main character if you will. And if you recall, the first four minutes of the film, 4 and a half in fact, starts off in silence. And it's our way of introducing the audience to not just the language of the film, but the thing, the material, the element that's going to be kind of leading you through the journey of watching that film throughout.
And so yeah, it was important for us to let silence like have its own voice in the film and give it ample time and space for it to be whatever it is and wants to be for the audience when they're watching it. We try not to be prescriptive with the film. Like we don't talk about meditation and you know like this is how you should engage with silence or this is what it is exactly. That's really for the viewer to kind of decide and interpret on their own depending on kind of where they're at in their lives and where they're coming at it from.
So yeah, it was important for us to kind of weave silence as a voice throughout.
Right. Right. And with the sound actually cuz that was actually going to be my first question. So, for example, this in I know in the first four minutes there's scenes where you have cars driving past and when I was listening to it, I had headphones on it the cars driving past it sounded so crisp. So, that was built in post that wasn't recorded on location.
Let me try to remember that particular shot. Most of the film was recorded on location and you know as is the case with most documentaries that go to post have some kind of post-production sound element done to it. You know you use your production sound as much as possible and that really kind of forms the foundation of the sound mix. But what sound designers will do is they'll kind of build out environments and atmospheres around your production sound to kind of fill it out especially if you're doing like a surround mix like we did. You know, there were actually a few times when we had a special mic.
It's called a holophone microphone with five mics built into this like enclosure. So, there were times when we used that on location to try and gather as much like sonic information as possible. But even with those recordings, the sound designers, you know, they have their own touch that they want to add to these things and make it even more immersive and more you know, articulate the nuances of those spaces. And so even then, you know, the sound designers add their little touch to it.
I feel like yes, story elements can keep us active and we okay, we realize, okay, here's the arc, here's the this character, this is their struggle, but I rarely see films these days that actually keep us active like experientially. So I feel like it seems like that's a running theme of your work to you know keep the viewer active in that sense.
Totally. Yeah. I some I heard this phrase the other day like lean in cinema rather than lean back cinema I think is what they said. And I like this idea of people engaging with the work you know like there's a time and place to watch movies like whatever Mission: Impossible or whatever. Like I love those movies watching with those movies with my kids and it's like it's those are fun. Those are spectacle and a type of cinema all on their own, but I think when I want something a little bit more engaging, like I want to lean into the thing, like I want to I want to I want to feel my way through something, you know, and not just kind of passively consume something.
With that film there's a phrase that's mentioned in the film at one point that silence is a sound and so we struggled with that a lot it's like okay if silence is a sound like there's no such thing as absolute silence as John Cage famously said and you experience it when you step into an anechoic chamber of course like even in an anechoic chamber that's designed to be 99% soundproof and there's just absolutely no reverberations like you hear things. Your body starts to kind of invent things for you to hear if it's not your own bodily sounds like your heartbeat or even for some people with like really good hearing can hear the blood flow through their veins in that room allegedly.
You know, you still hear something, right? And it's because we're just not designed. We're not designed for a void of sound. Obviously, we were made with ears for a reason. And they're designed to pick up signals and so it's very disorienting when there's nothing in the soundtrack. So but so I think when a filmmaker does that when they just strip away the sound entirely I think it's a really bold choice and I think more people need to do fun and bold things like that to kind of like make the audiences lean in. There is one moment in Pursuit of Silence where we do strip away the sound entirely and that's when we step into the anechoic chamber cuz we found you know we're making a point there in that film that it's negative 13 dB below the human threshold of hearing and so how do you how do you illustrate that in a film you know like we thought you know we recorded the sound like with our own gear but you know as you know all filmmakers out there know like gear has its own self-noise like the mechanics inside the device have a sound to them and so in a room that's -3 dB you're going to hear the sound of the machine you know and so you know our recordings were fine like there are nice clean recordings used the best recorder Sound Devices 633 I think was the recorder we used but even then there's like a little hiss to it and so we just stripped it out entirely just to kind of make it even more jarring for people to give them some sense of what that might feel like it's fun to play with that kind of stuff so we went to two anechoic chambers for the filming of In Pursuit of Silence.
And the first one that we visited was the anechoic chamber at Orfield Labs in Minnesota. And that's the one at the time that was on record as being the quietest place on the in the world 13 dB. Since then, I think Microsoft's anechoic chamber I think in Washington has beat that. They're -15, I believe. Anyway, so I had read all these reports of people going crazy and starting to hallucinate after 40 minutes. And so I told the guys at the anechoic chamber facility, I was like, "Put me in there, turn off all the lights. I want as much sensory deprivation as possible. You know, I'm going to lay down on the floor."
They gave me a pillow. I'm going to lay down on the floor, all the lights off, and come and get me in 40 minutes and, you know, see how I'm doing. And you know I didn't go crazy but there was definitely like there's definitely like this the inner chatter all of a su when the white noise of everything like your the sonic environment that you're in. You know the notifications and your work and like all the thoughts are running through your brain. When all the white noise kind of falls away and you're just left in a room with your yourself the inner chatter just like kicks into like high gear and it's crazy.
It's just like there's constant chatter. And it's hard to it's hard to kind of minimize that. And you know, it took me maybe 15 20 minutes or so before I settled into that experience and was able to just quiet my brain and quiet my thoughts and deal with just the sound of the room and myself. And before I knew it, you know, the door was being opened up. So, I felt like I could have went longer and I kind of wished I had. But yeah, maybe I'll go back and give it a shot. But yeah, I it's not it's not for everybody. It's pretty, you know, like I said, it's super disorienting.
When you walk into a space, you're just you're used to hearing the sound of the space. When you talk in the room, you're getting cues from the reverberations. You know, how long it takes your voice to bounce back at you tells you gives you some orientation of where you are in that space. In that room, you speak and it just kind of falls to nothing. And it's super weird. Yeah. It's it could be scary, I think, for people for some people who just aren't used to that.
Yeah. I can't even begin to like imagine cuz I feel like I've got like tinnitus. I feel like I've got that. So, to be in a room where I have to like reconcile with that, amongst other things that I'm hearing. Yeah, I think I'd probably last like 5 minutes. I'm not I'm not even joking. I think I'd really I don't know how I unless there was money at the end of it or something other than my own like driving force. I don't know how I could do it. I don't know.
But form of torture form of torture really, you know, it's like I said, we're just not made for that. It's really hard to kind of get through. So, I have tinnitus, too. And that was one of the first things that I noticed about myself. And I hadn't didn't know that until I stepped in the room how bad my tinnitus was. I played in like metal bands and stuff growing up. And so, I suspected that I probably had damaged my hearing to some extent, but I didn't know it was that bad until I stepped in that room. And so, that was the other thing that I had to kind of contend with and just manage in the room.
And then since then, I can't help but notice my tinnitus when I'm in a quiet space, which is super annoying, of course. And part of me wishes I'd never stepped into that anechoic chamber for that reason, but yeah.
Yeah. It's not something to be for the faint of heart, let's say. But actually speaking about your metal band I guess upbringing and history. What was the the link between metal band and documentary film making? What was the bridge?
The bridge from metal music to film making. That's interesting. I mean, you know, I it was music was my first love. And I think I'm just this type of person, like a lot of artists are, this type of person that feels more comfortable expressing oneself through artistic means, you know, and so like I that was my way of speaking to the world. Like I appreciated that having that channel more than I did having my own voice, you know what I mean? Like it was just the way I spoke to the world. So, you know, that's that was really the bridge. When I discovered film, it was just kind of like finding another language that I could use to speak to the world and speak into the things that I cared about.
I don't know, just like it was easier for me to articulate myself through music in film. And then you know I was an existentially curious kid, teenager was really into like Native American spirituality and Buddhism and I would just dive into all these spirituality books. And so when I started making films I just I naturally started to kind of pursue these ideas with my film making as a means to just kind of work out some ideas and work out things that I was thinking about or struggling with at the time. But yeah, it's funny. Metal a metal former metal musician, you know, making a film about silence doesn't sound quite right.
But you know, it's like I there's a time and place for noise. There's a time and place for metal and there's a time and place for silence, you know, like we need both. We need both to appreciate both ends of the spectrum, you know, and so I'm not I'm not a silence evangelist in a in that way. I do appreciate all forms of sound.
Right. Right. But I guess it's kind of like, you know, when you hear of obviously it's not like a onetoone correlation, but when you hear of like someone who had been, I don't know, like a drug addict ends up being like the drug counselor because they've, you know, dealt with all these like vices. So they've actually experienced it. So they're the best person to, you know, give advice to people also struggling. Maybe all the, you know, high decibel environments you had of metal made you the best person to make a film about no noise.
I never thought about that. You're right. It's probably true. Yeah.
Yeah. But actually speaking about film because I did I did see on a previous interview you mentioned that you don't watch that many films. Is that still correct?
I don't watch a lot of films. That's that is true. My when I teach my documentary classes, people are always a little surprised to hear that I actually don't watch a lot of documentaries. I'll watch a handful a year maybe. And then films. I just gosh, you know, I love films. I'm a student of cinema. I do consider myself a student of cinema and I do love cinematic language, but I don't know. I guess I find way more enjoyment making films than I do watching them, I guess. And I just haven't I don't carve out as much time as I should to watch films.
I have a long list of films that I want to watch just like everybody else. But I do I get so much out of making films that I just find myself so busy and too busy to make time to watch a bunch of movies. You know, I wish it were different and you know, I'm working on that. But I enjoy the film making, man. And you know I used to go to when I was starting out in the film business I used to go to these LA like networking things where they would have like directors roundtables and you go hear directors speak and stuff and I would go year after year and I would talk to the same people.
I'd run into the same people like shopping their same script like looking for people to make their movies and it's like years and years later they're still kind of like in the same spot. And there's I think there's something to be said about the people who they just they lock in at home or in their studios and they just they commit themselves to making the thing rather than seeking advice and going out in the world and seeking trying to find the inspiration all the time. You know what's that famous saying? Inspiration has to find you working, you know. So anyway, that's the kind of school of thought that I've come from, but not to say that I dislike watching movies.
I very much enjoy. I just don't have a lot of time for it. What I also really enjoy doing is pulling inspiration from other disciplines. I think that makes the craft way more interesting. Something I talk to students about all the time. It's like your originality as a filmmaker is directly linked to the things that you're consuming, the people that are influencing you. So if you're just watching movies that came out in the last couple years or whatever, your films are probably going to look and feel like things that came out in the last couple years. And maybe you're okay with that. That's completely fine, of course.
But man, there's a breadth of super interesting creative stuff in art in the world that has been done over the years, over the centuries that we should be pulling from, that we should be allowing into our process. Timeless stuff that speak has been speaking to audiences for centuries, you know what I mean? And so there's like so much great material out there. So I like to cast the net as wide as possible when it comes to what I allow into my process and what I'm influenced by.
But as you're speaking about festivals so when In Pursuit of Silence played at CPH:DOX played at you know South by Southwest obviously I know CPH:DOX for the documentary world it's like you know it's right at the top there and obviously South by Southwest you know generally it's one of the top you know film festivals in the world. When you're taking your film to these festivals and it's your film like what is that experience like? Like especially for a feature film cuz I know for shorts you know there's less of you know notoriety there but for you know a feature film what is it like premiering there?
Yeah, I you know it's such a honor to be invited to screen at those big festivals because those audiences you know they've done those big festivals have done such a good job curating their programming over the years and develop and cultivating a loyal audience around their screenings and around their programs to where like you can just you feel it when you're at those festivals that people are there to really appreciate the works that they have curated and presented to their audience and so audiences are just excited to be there. They're engaged. You know we had how many screenings did we have? I feel like we had two at least.
And they're both sold out screenings and again really great audiences. And so that's the gift of a festival that really understands their personality as a film festival and does such a good job curating the experience that the audience is just super fired up to be there and you're rewarded with like a big audience who asks great questions and really kind of understands your work. So that's awesome. I've been to plenty of other festivals that don't do that well that cultivation and curation very well and there's 30 people in the theater and you know like it that's those can still be rewarding experiences cuz you never know who's in the audience but I've been to yeah f plenty of festivals that are dramatically different than that and really just are in the in this they're in what am I trying to say?
These smaller festivals that don't do as well at that, they are in the business of basically just kind of throwing movies up onto a screen, filling up their program, and getting as many sponsorships as they possibly can to pay for all this stuff. And it's not it doesn't just doesn't feel very special. Anyway, so getting into a big festival like that is it's a hustle, you know, because you're thinking about you're thinking about capitalizing on not just the audience, the buzz, and creating that buzz, but you're also thinking about press, what kind of press opportunities there might be and who you need to be speaking with.
You're also thinking about potential buyers and agents that you might speak with at some of these festivals. You know, the days are kind of long and gone where you go to a festival and you like get the big deal and there's all these like crazy bidding wars over films. It just doesn't really happen as much anymore. But industry still does pay attention to these big festivals. They're looking at, if they're not attending themselves, they're definitely looking at the program when it's released and they're looking at the films that kind of speak to them or align with their vision as a company or whatever and they're reaching out for screeners.
And so it's good to be part of those festivals regardless. But yeah, man, it's it's weeks and weeks of preparation. Kind of getting all your ducks in a row and making whatever contacts and setting up whatever meetings you can at these events and then thinking about the event itself and how to make it a special experience because these days we know it's hard to get people in theaters and even then this was 10 years ago. It was it's hard to people it's hard to get people in the theaters and really engage with it. And so you always have to find ways to kind of like eventize your screenings in a way.
And so we had performances before our screenings. In fact, we had a local like local performers come like musicians perform John Cage's 4 minutes and 33 seconds before the all the screenings. And so they would get up there and if you're unfamiliar with that piece of music by John Cage, it's a performer gets up there for 4 minutes and 33 seconds and does nothing. And so we had like a well-known musician get up there and do nothing for 4 and 1/2 minutes and then we'd start the film. And then we we partnered with an artist who just so happens was had created an installation for South by Southwest that he was I forget what he was calling it, but it was a silent room installation that he was going to put in the middle of like one of the busiest, you know, you know, intersections in the South By kind of area.
And so we partnered with him to make sure that everyone who attended our film screening would be able to get like front of the line to walk into this. It's basically an anechoic chamber that he built in the middle of South by Southwest, one of the loudest festivals in the world. And so yeah, it was stars align for sure on that front for a film at yeah so there's a lot of considerations that you're making but it's super fun and rewarding to be at a festival like that
And yeah so ju just on cuz you mentioned a collaborator you said Brandon Vedder right? Yeah. I s cuz I had a look. Is he the filmmaker that you're collaborating on the 600-year long project?
That's right. Yeah. We have two films. We have two films in the works. One of the films is called As Slow as Possible, and it centers around a musical performance that's been going on in Halberstadt, Germany, small medieval German town since 2001. And it's been continuously performed and it won't complete until 2640. So in total it's a 639-year long performance of a piece of music. And so that's kind of like the foundational narrative of that film. And our goal ultimately and maybe this is partly what you were referring to. Our goal ultimately is for this just to be one installment of this kind of maybe like a film series if you will and like subsequent generations will continue making different installments of this film for the next 600 years so that it finally premieres the final installment will premiere alongside the conclusion of that performance in Halberstadt, Germany in 2640 or 2641.
That's the plan, the grand plan, but we're kind of just focusing on the first film right now and trying to get that done. But yeah, we got another film too that we're making about two celebrated avant-garde filmmakers, Nathaniel Dorsky and Jerome Hiler. Nathaniel Dorsky is the one that you kind of referenced at the very beginning of this interview. He's the one that taught me that films should be of rather than about something. Or at least that's a that's a direction that one can take. And I think in a best case scenario, I think a film could be should be of and about. I don't know.
But again, it's a that's a creative choice. Anyhow, yeah, Brandon Vedder, that's who I'm collaborating with on those two films, right?
Nice. And the so the 639 year project. I'm curious because obviously we probably won't be around in 2640, but when the project is finished, have you guys, I guess like currently as you're working on the project now, have you thought about what the world might even look like, you know, then and like how the film would be you know, watched and experienced. I guess it's hard to look, you know, forward 50 years, let alone, you know, adding 600 years onto that. But have you had any thoughts of how it will be watched then?
You know, no, not really. Our hope is that there will be a world that exists in 600 years. You know what I mean? I you know, and I think that's what the organizers of this performance always talk about. They're like, we don't know what the world's going to be like. Like there might be some crazy climate disaster. A tornado might come through town and just wipe out the fac. It's housed within this old medieval church that's like 600 years old and there just this organ in the middle of this church. And so they're just like, you know, there might be a tornado, some crazy natural disaster that comes through and destroys everything at some point and then it's over.
There may not be people left in this town to appreciate this musical performance in 200 years, 300 years, whatever. But ultimately, it's a message of hope that there will be something and that this is something that they can hand off to subsequent generations and have them carry on this tradition and think about. Ultimately, what this project does is it makes you think about longterm long-term thinking, right? And it makes you think about time as this less concrete, less ticking clock, industrial clock kind of concept and thinks about it more on like I don't know you could call it a cosmic level or even geographic kind of level where you know mountains are formed over millions of years right that's geological time and then the cosmic time sort of the ticking clock of the universe right where things happen over billions of years and so this is just a project to get us kind of out of this narrow way of thinking about time, this ticking clock that really was devised to kind of keep factories worker workers in check or it was designed to kind of schedule and time and calculate shipments and that kind of thing in the industrial age.
So it's totally it's totally a construct, right? It's trees and rivers and the earth itself. They tell time on a different scale. And so this project is kind of designed to do that just to kind of like dislodge us and divorce us from one way of thinking about time.
No, that makes sense. And I think you know as obviously going back to the the creative direction of making a film of you know as well as about I think taking 639 years is you know there's no I guess more way you could do it of time than you know stretching it over those centuries. So I guess yeah there's you can see the synergy there. I guess think thinking about the future this is a you know the best segue to talk about AI and I guess firstly I would love to know how did you come across Eddie AI? How did that enter your world?
Where did you find that?
That's a good question. I don't remember exactly where I first came upon it. It was probably social media or something. I imagine maybe a YouTube video or something. And I've been quite interested in AI as is the industry as a whole. But I think specifically for documentary filmmakers, AI, especially independent like documentary filmmakers that have small teams and small budgets, right? There's extra appeal to these AI tools. And so, I've been thinking about it a lot. So when Eddie AI came on the scene I was really intrigued with the idea of like all of a sudden being able to free myself up of the editing assistant kind of you know tasks.
And AI in general I think has that promise right to you know it's the best intern it's the best sort of admin assistant that you could possibly have. It's the best research assistant I think that you could possibly have. And it, you know, I've been using AI to do those sort of tasks for the past, I would say, year or so. And it's been magical, man. Like, it's really freed me up. It's freed up my brain to be more creative and think about the things that actually like excite me. And it enables me to kind of think be more efficient as a creative person.
So yeah, I think it must have been a social media post to answer your question directly, right?
Yeah. And I think I think the use case for AI in you know documentary film making where you can feasibly have you know hundreds upon hundreds of hours of footage to just ingest and log and find. It's like, yeah, if you can bring it down to, you know, you know, 10% of the time that you would have, you know, originally spent, it's like if you have next to no money to spend on a project, it's like it's a no-brainer, isn't it? It's like, let's be real.
Totally. Totally. Yeah. Yeah. I will say what's what what has prevented me from adopting it like wholesale all across the board for everything that I do. Is this idea is this idea that to make the films that the kind of films that I make it's important and I would argue for most filmmakers it's important to like know your footage intimately right and it's not just the dialogue which I think a lot of these models are kind of driven on right it's kind of sorting through your dialogue and stuff but it's like the nuances and it's the behavioral stuff that's in your footage that's hard for AI to kind of decode and provide some kind of context around.
And so sometimes, you know, for these longer form films, I think at the end of the day, you still have to kind of watch the footage. But I think what AI can do and I specifically Eddie AI can do is give you a head start on all that. You know, like I think, you know, even with Eddie AI as a you know, as a part of my process, I'll still I still expect to watch the footage at some point, but I think to be able to kind of understand, for example, I just get back from a shoot and I just want to kind of understand what we got.
I want like some selects pulled from what we just shot. Even if it's just the B-roll. And I want to just kind of like be able to consume or absorb what it is that we just did because, you know, often these shoots are like whirlwinds, you know, like you're just you're going from shoot to shoot, location to location, and you're just like gathering hundreds and you know, hour terabytes and terabytes of footage. And it's like you have to have some way of engaging with that stuff without having to sit down right away and watch every frame of it. You know, that's where the editing process, you know, but sometimes you just need to understand kind of where your story's at, you know, and I think that's where Eddie AI and platforms like that are really promising.
Yeah, I think there's a few documentary filmmakers that I know have kind of adopted that same process of almost like just getting out of the gate, you know, just to like get it out, you know, see where you are. And obviously, you know, once you get into the, you know, the deeper edit, then of course, yes, sitting through, you know, getting the nuances, you know, just even like a facial expression that you can capture for like 2 3 seconds, you know, all of those things I think make the difference. In terms of especially for like you know narrative feature film long form yeah feature films I think definitely I think one thing that's kind of been like playing in my mind is have you seen or heard or experienced documentary filmmakers using generative AI because I understand the I the fears with narrative because we're already dealing with technically stories that are reimagined or don't necessarily exist.
So I think those kind of you know stories are I guess you could say more susceptible to okay being generated because technically it's all make believe anyway. But I know filmmakers using generative AI for like essentially replacing stock what stock footage used to be. But I just wonder if we get into the point where cuz I guess you could say you know truth in documentary has always kind of been a point of contention. I guess would generative AI could we get to a point where you know interviews or you know or I don't know like you know scenes with subjects are being generated like I feel like that could get quite murky in terms of ethically and morally.
I don't know what your thoughts are on that.
Totally. Yeah. Totally. You know, at USC, this whole AI evolution, how quickly it's evolving, it's obviously happening at rapid pace. And so, at USC, departmentwide in the cinematic arts department, as of last semester anyway, like I said, I'm not teaching this semester, so I'm not sure if they've developed a departmentwide AI policy. And so, we were left as professors to kind of come up with our own policies for our own classes. And so in my class, I specifically said, "We are not allowing generative AI to be used in this class." but the non-generative stuff to help you draft things and do your research, go nuts.
And so in from what I gather, from people I talk to and from films I see, conversations happening in the doc space, generally speaking, I think that's where they draw the line. And I think when it comes to generative AI, there are films, of course, famous examples like the Anthony Bourdain film that came out, when was that? I don't know, four years ago or something like that, where they generated excerpts of Anthony Bourdain's emails and had an AI read his emails for use in the film. There are famous examples of people playing with these things. I and I think gosh, you know, these documentaries, they have a they do truth is kind of baked into the contract, right?
And we all when we make documentary films, non-fiction films, we have a there's a claim to truth that's baked into the presentation. And I think audiences have come to expect when they step into an audience to watch a non-fiction piece that there's going to be some kind of truth communicated to them, that there's something true about the world, they're going to see something true about the world on the screen. And so I could see for certain cases where generative AI could be potentially used so long as there's transparency with the audience, you know, and I think that's at the end of the day, it's really about transparency.
It's about the contract that you make with the audience. What is it that your film is trying to get at? What is the truth that your film is trying to get at? If you can use AI, I suppose to further a truth then I don't see why not. So long as again you're transparent with the audience. You know, we there's all sort of like cinematic tricks and smoke and mirrors that we employ, you know, when we make films, non-fiction or otherwise, you know, like it's at the end of the day, it's a particular interpretation of truth, right? As filmmakers are putting up on screen kind of a metaphor for a particular truth.
You know, we find particular images and sounds and we find ways to juxtapose all those things together to kind of get at our idea of what truth is as it relates to the subject of the film. And so none of it's, you know, we're not reading a document. We're watching a piece of creative cinema on screen, right? And so I think, you know, I there I think that people should consider that AI is not the boogeyman that many make it out to be and consider it as part of our toolkit. Again, so long as it's being used in an ethical way and it's being used in a transparent way.
Totally. I saw a great short documentary. It might have even been mentioned in the Rough Cut newsletter. I can't remember where I came across it. It's a short documentary about reimagining the the mission to the moon and if it were to I think it was reimagining if it were to if it if the shuttle exploded in route to our first experience on the moon the mission to the moon. And it was like all AI generated. And I think they used a speech of Nixon's that was pre-written. If things were you did write about this, that was fascinating, man. Like, it's so interesting. And again, like there's a contract with me at the very beginning watching.
I was like, I know this is going to be all AI generated. But this is the truth of what they're trying to get at. Like there's some emotional truth here. Like what would have happened? So of course that works for me you know so I think there are cases where it's okay to use I think yeah
I think reimagining you know what could have been I think is a very interesting use case and actually this week's newsletter will touch upon that there's actually another podcast I think it's called Films Not Made which is about all the Hollywood films that did not get made like through development hell or whatever else and they're using gener generative AI to imagine stills, trailers of these films that have never been made. So, I think that could be super interesting just to see, okay, maybe this shouldn't have got made or maybe, oh, we've missed out on, you know, this hidden gem, you know? I think that could be super interesting.
That's cool.
Well, we're coming up to the hour mark, so I think it's it's been a super yeah, interesting dive into to your work, you know, how you think about the world, you know, film. How should people look out for you? Where should they find your work? How should they interact with you?
I the best way to see my work is maybe go to patrickshen.com. And or reach out to me over Instagram, patshen. Yeah. Yeah. But yeah, thanks for having me on the podcast, man. Big fans of what you guys are doing and developing. It just keeps on getting better and better. I'm psyched to dive in a little bit more in this latest iteration of the platform.
Nice, man. Been an absolute pleasure. And thank you again for being our first guest. First of many, but it's been yeah, great to get someone who's already part of the ecosystem. I think it's a nice way to start this off. Yeah, so guys, that was the first episode of the Rough Cut podcast, and like I said, we'll be doing many more of these and yeah, I will speak to all you guys soon.