What the episode covers
Her test for AI is the contract with the audience. A cloned voice or a generated scene can add to a film when viewers know it is there and why; it crosses the line when they don't. She keeps that creative question apart from a second one: AI that makes editing faster, cheaper and easier.
Key moments
- 01
An internship found on Craigslist
Lingo was finishing pre-med when she answered a Craigslist posting for an internship at Jigsaw Productions, Alex Gibney's company. Assembling the delivery binder for Taxi to the Dark Side taught her the paperwork of a documentary: releases, schedules, budgets. Her first paid documentary job followed, with Jehane Noujaim.
Read this part of the transcript - 02
How documentaries got made in the 2000s
DV cameras, tapes digitized into Final Cut Pro and the spread of the internet lowered the cost of entry. Films were financed by selling rights territory by territory, and documentaries could still do well in theaters.
Read this part of the transcript - 03
The audience didn't leave, it moved
Lingo says documentaries are the fourth most popular category on subscription and free streaming services. People watch them at home now rather than in theaters, which is why she disagrees with talk of a lost golden age.
Read this part of the transcript - 04
How Op-Docs grew out of the op-ed page
Authors promote their books with op-eds; Op-Docs asked documentary filmmakers to make short films from their features in the same way. Jason Spingarn-Koff launched it in 2011 and hired Lingo to help grow it. Early films came from Penny Lane, Laura Poitras, Alex Gibney and Errol Morris.
Read this part of the transcript - 05
What an Oscar campaign for a short costs now
For Our Curse in 2014, Op-Docs hired a publicist who had the documentary branch voters' emails and held screenings. Today, emailing Oscar voters goes through the Academy, which charges thousands of dollars. Her advice: be honest about the cost, and treat the campaign as a way to meet people and promote yourself as a director.
Read this part of the transcript - 06
The streaming gold rush, and why she left
From 2018 to 2021 streamers were writing big checks for documentaries. By 2024 they wanted mass-appeal projects such as true crime and celebrity, which she wasn't excited to make, and she was ready for a new chapter.
Read this part of the transcript - 07
Where AI crosses the line
She separates rules that don't matter, like turning off an air conditioner for clean audio, from deception. AI imagery of New York in 1942, or of a family at dinner, needs the audience to know it is AI and why. Sarah Polley's Stories We Tell, which reveals that its Super 8 footage was shot for the film, is her example of doing it honestly.
Read this part of the transcript - 08
Substack as a calling card
Writing is her solo outlet after years of filmmaking as a team sport. She says Substack hasn't made her much money, but it builds an audience between films and brings in consulting work.
Read this part of the transcript
In Kathleen's words
“In life, it's not who you know, it's who knows you.”
Advice to directors running an Oscar campaign “The audience needs to be in on it.”
On AI-generated scenes in documentary “Truth is a complicated thing.”
On which documentary rules actually matter “I'm also very much a critic of people who say documentaries are dead, the golden age is over. I just don't think the data bears that out.”
On the state of documentary “Our work is only as valuable as the audience it has.”
On why filmmakers should build an audience between films
Short clips from the episode
Audience in on it
Her two AI conversations, and why a generated scene needs the audience to know.
On YouTube soonDocs alive
Why she isn't pessimistic: documentaries are the fourth most popular category on streaming.
On YouTube soonTruth is complicated
Straightened pillows and switched-off air conditioners: which documentary rules matter.
On YouTube soonWho knows you
Using an Oscar campaign to meet people in the documentary community.
On YouTube soon
THE GUEST
Kathleen Lingo
Documentary producer, writer of Lingo on Docs
THE OTHER AI CONVERSATION
AI that speeds up the edit, not footage that never happened.
Lingo's second AI conversation is about making editing faster, cheaper and easier. For interviews, that is where Eddie works: every interview is transcribed and searchable, and a search across a project's transcripts for a phrase, topic or speaker returns the matching segments with timestamps.
Full transcript
Transcribed from the episode video and lightly cleaned: filler words (um, uh) and repeated words are removed and misheard names are corrected. Quotes on this page are taken from this transcript.
Read the transcript 8,143 words
Hey guys, so this is the second episode of the Rough Cut podcast and today we have Kathleen Lingo. She is a subscriber to the Rough Cut Substack and formerly of the New York Times where she ran Op-Docs produced hundreds of documentaries, four Emmys, three Oscar-nominated films. And she left in 2024 and since has been running her own Substack Lingo on Docs where she talks about documentary film making and it was on Substack that we connected I really wanted to hear her thoughts on film making documentaries where we're headed her history AI of course and yeah And that's what brings us to this discussion today.
So, yeah, Kathleen, thank you so much for jumping on and yeah, great to have you.
Thanks for having me. I'm excited to chat. I'm a big fan of your Substack and everything you write about. So, I'm was very intrigued when you reached out and I'm really excited for this conversation.
Great. Thank you. Obviously yeah thank you for reading all the posts and yeah I think it should be an interesting discussion. I mean I would love to just start from the beginning because I read that am I correct in saying that you started in documentary film making via a Craigslist ad. Is that how this all began? Like you have to unpack that.
Yeah. Well, I'll I was always into journalism from a very young age. Like when I was in fifth grade, I wrote the astrology column for the school newspaper. And you know, in high school, I was editor of the school newspaper. And I was actually a music journalist in my late teens and early 20s. I wrote a lot about drum and bass, which is very familiar to anyone in the UK. For those of you in the US, it's a form of electronic music that was created in London in the 90s. So, I have deep roots in journalism and I love reporting. I'm just a super curious person and the ability to put on your reporter hat or your documentary producer hat and ask people anything to me is like what makes me excited to live life.
And so I was interested in all of that, but I was actually premed and I was planning to become a doctor. People don't think about this, but when you're a doctor, it's sort of similar to being a journalist because you can ask anyone anything. And as I was finishing up my premed, I was also feeling stressed and like, is this really what I want to do? And a very good friend of mine had just finished a master's in documentary at NYU. And so we sort of talking started talking about documentary and working documentary. So I started to sort of dip my toes in with her and you know we will get a camera and just play around and I was interested.
So I just looked on Craigslist for any jobs in doc and I saw a posting for an internship at Jigsaw Productions. I didn't know what that was, so I Googled it and it was the production company of Alex Gibney who'd won an Oscar for Enron. And I thought, "Oh, that sounds cool." You know, being an unpaid intern can sound unglamorous and maybe even some would say unfair because you're working for free. But the truth is I learned so much, you know, just by, you know, back then it was still paper and one of my jobs was they were delivering Taxi to the Dark Side, which is a film that won an Oscar.
I guess that was in 2007. And so before everything was digital, every film had something called a delivery binder that the producer would have to deliver to the distributor. So my job was to like literally go through files and find all the appearance releases and the schedules and the budgets. But what an incredible way to learn about film making. I immediately learned sort of the brass tacks of what it takes to make a documentary. And I did research for different projects for Alex and you know just being in that environment. Alison Ellwood, who's a director and an editor, was working there editing. The producer who hired me is Ali Johnes who's had an incredible career as a documentary producer as well.
Sam Black was the other intern. He's gone on to have a great career. So it was just a you know sort of my first peak into the world. And then of course one needs to get paid and so I was always searching for jobs you know to get actual paycheck and I did working for Jehane Noujaim, which people will would know probably her documentary The Square which was the first documentary Netflix ever acquired but she also did Control Room she did The Vow series for HBO so at that point she had just won a TED prize and the prize was to do whatever she wanted with some insane amount of money and what she wanted to do was to create a television broadcast for short documentaries that could be seen all around the world.
So, I got to be a production assistant and then I was promoted to assistant editor because what I ended up doing was taking all, you know, once we had chosen the films and all of that, getting them on physical tapes and I had to drive them to this place in upstate New York to get captioning on all of them in like seven languages. So, that was my first paid job. And docs,
Wow. I mean, all from a Craigslist. I mean, that's such a great endorsement of just, you know, just taking an opportunity on a not even a jobs board. It's you know, just kind of like random posting and it just being the kickstarter for a whole career. But I guess when how back when you were working your way up through the being an assistant and assistant editor, how what was the documentary landscape back then? How were documentaries getting made at least compared to how they're getting made now? Was there a huge difference?
I mean, in many ways, where we are now is where we were then. You know, this was 2007, 2008. It definitely felt like there was more and more interest in documentary. The biggest game in town was HBO, but there were still theatrical distributors that were buying docs, putting them in theaters. Docs did relatively well in theaters back then. I mean, I was actually just doing some research on this yesterday about the theatrical market for documentaries, you know, which has really gone down in the past few years because of streaming and just audience appetites for going to the theater for docs has just really plummeted overall.
But, you know, back then like Michael Moore, I think it was Fahrenheit 9/11 made $100 million at the box office. I want to Google that and fact check it. It was either that or Bowling for Columbine. But all that to say, there were big documentary hits in theaters. Sicko, Sicko was huge. And really shaping the culture and the conversation and it felt like at that moment in time, especially with technology changing, there was a lower bar to entry. I mean so much of the history of film is about technology and I think often times we don't kind of talk about that enough but basically the story with documentary was you know back in the ' 40s to the '60s it you know it was you know 16 mm film sync sound it was expensive and it was complicated to do you know with the rise of video technology in the '9s by the early 2000s there were these Sony and Panason Panasonic cameras that you could put a DV tape in that had a shotgun on the top and you could make great movies on those things.
And that was really a democratizing force, you know, whereas like the Maysles brothers had literally been shooting on film and cutting it on a flatbed. Now you could just get a camera and do it yourself. And then with digitization, you know, when we have when we used to shoot on tapes, then there were decks and the deck was where you put in the tape and then you digitize it and then it be on your computer and then you could edit it with Final Cut Pro. So the tools were all of a sudden readily available and at the same time you had the rise of the internet.
So you had the rise of the internet, you had the changing technology to make films. So by the early and mid 2000s there was an explosion of creativity because the barrier to entry had gone down so much and also remember it was the rise of reality television with the real world and everything that come in the '90s. So there was just more and more interest I feel like in rough true documentary style storytelling and I think it was just like for me a right place right time moment. And so, you know, there were all these distribution deals that where you could really make money, unlike now selling rights to, you know, cable in Spain or public television in France, theatrical in Germany, theatrical in North America.
And through doing all these different rights deals, you could literally make enough money to make a film and make a living. And then as you know that I mean that was the classic way that all films were made. It wasn't just docs fiction too, right? It was like a piecemeal funding model and you would sell territories and time periods and then at the end of the day you would make money in residuals as the films, you know, kept being distributed, being watched, and the checks would pour in. And all of that, of course, changed with Netflix, but I don't want to jump ahead too much, but that was sort of where things were in the 2000s.
And especially in New York, there were a lot of great directors. Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady were up and coming at that time. And I remember being sort of obsessed with them, like a huge fan girl. So, it was just it was exciting. It felt like there were opportunities in the air. There was money. There were jobs. And it felt like we could, you know, for people my age, many of whom I'm still friends with, you know, we felt like we could have careers and do this forever. Where things are now is totally different.
Right. Right. And I mean, I can even think back to yeah, some mega docs. Obviously you had, you know, Fahrenheit 9/11. I forget the name, but what was the name of the Al Gore doc? The one that he did?
Oh yeah. An Inconvenient Truth.
Inconvenient Truth. And then another one that I watched back then that I don't know how big it was globally, but Super Size Me was that quite a that was a big one as well. And I feel like we have big docs now, but they don't seem to have the same like cultural cache that you know those mega docs have. It'd almost be like people who don't even watch anything might have watched those, you know, documentaries, you know, even at the cinema. Like I knew people that I went to school with and their parents going to see, you know, Fahrenheit 9/11 at the cinema. And I feel like that would be near unheard of now for like people casual, you know, consumers of entertainment to go to cinema to watch documentaries.
I just don't I don't really hear of it these days.
Yeah, again I was just researching this yesterday and the interesting thing is the appetite for documentaries is super high. It's the fourth most popular category of content in for streaming both subscription streaming and free streaming services. So I actually think the world has just changed and the good news is people still love documentaries but they are habituated to watching them at home and they're not something that people feel motivated to go out and watch in a theater because remember everyone was talking about Fahrenheit 9/11 but the only way you could see it was in a theater so you didn't have another option. Now if there's a film like Fahrenheit 9/11 you think oh well it'll probably be on Netflix soon.
So I, you know, I can't make it to the movie theater. You know, I have kids or work or whatever. So I think that's really that's really it. It's just a shift in behavior, but it's not it's actually the audience has grown. And I feel like there's a lot of opportunity there. And that's why I actually am not doom and gloom about the future of documentary film making the way that others are. I think there's a bigger audience than ever and I think it's incumbent on us as filmmakers to think about where the opportunities are and how to meet the audience so that they will watch our stuff.
You know, I don't think we live in a time and honestly this time never existed where you could just make whatever you want, put it out there, it would premiere at Sundance and millions of people would watch it. And I think that a lot of what I see is st people have strange ideas about how film making how films get distributed and how they meet audiences that have nothing to do with the reality of the situation. So I'm also very much a critic of people who say documentaries are dead, the golden age is over. I just don't think the data bears that out.
Right. Yeah. And I think when you mention, you know, people looking for opportunities and obviously having platforms, I think that's a good segue into actually talking about Op-Docs because that wasn't something that New York Times always had, right? That only started what 2011 and you joined 2 years after that. Is that correct?
Yeah. So, Op-Docs is another really good example of how larger cultural changes around the internet and technology created an opportunity. So, the New York Times has something called the op-ed page, which it when no one just read the physical newspaper, there was like the main section of the newspaper and the last two pages were opinion and the sort of the last page was oped. And op-ed was a space for writers and thinkers from outside the New York Times to write essays on issues of the day. Like for example something about the war in Iran, you know, really pivoting off the news. But they also weren't always newsy.
They could be just more sort of zeitgeisty topics like kids relationship with technology. And the real truth of the matter is many of the people who write opeds are people who have books coming out. And one of the ways that authors promote their books is they pitch an op-ed to the New York Times on the same topic and then they write an essay and then at the bottom it says like their name and like the name of their book coming out. And someone at the New York Times before 2011 before Op-Docs started was aware of this rise in the popularity of documentaries which was happening at the same time and they thought hm you know and also I should mention the rise of online video you know we weren't on dialup anymore you know YouTube was a thing so it was like okay documentaries are more popular there's video online what if we make a video version of the op-ed page, but instead of authors writing short pieces based on their books, we ask documentaries, documentary filmmakers to make short documentaries based on their features as a way to promote them.
And that was the birth of Op-Docs. It really is so interesting to me how closely it evolved out of the op-ed page. Like it's almost a one-to-one, right? So that idea was born and then Jason Spingarn-Koff was the first person to lead Op-Docs and he's joined in 2011 and the series did well. So they said to him in 2012, why don't you hire someone to help you grow the series? And you know so much of in life is just like luck. And actually Ali Johnes, who'd hired me off of Craigslist, recommended me to him when cuz he was asking around town for who might be someone to, to hire for this role.
So, Ali Johnes is still a very good friend and is obviously changed my life by introducing me to Jason. And then I'm sure there competition was fierce, but I luckily landed this job. I had been a freelancer my whole life and to have even though the salary was nothing exciting. It was the first time in my life I had health insurance and paid vacations which the first year I was at the time was only 5 days but that to me was like incredible to be able to work on docs and also make a living. I will say that I had wanted to be a director up until that point.
And I was developing my own projects in that role, but I literally just gave up on that because a full-time job at the New York Times doing Op-Docs just seems so exciting. But I always like to give that context because often times directors will say to me, up-and-coming directors like, "How can I do this? How can I make it work?" And I always tell them the story like I wanted to be a director but I need a job. So I got one at Op-Docs. So Op-Docs was born in that moment and it was really exciting because there were all of these great films coming out.
We got to work with you know really famous people like Errol Morris but the first Op-Doc was also by fellow substacker Penny Lane. So, it was this mix of up-and-coming talent and established voices. Laura Poitras was an early contributor. Alex Gibney made one in the early days. So it really started as a way to bring more attention to this field of documentary that already had cultural currency and take advantage of this moment when video technology audiences were all aligning to bring more excitement around documentaries and also short documentaries. So when Op-Docs started sort of the only game in town for short documentaries was HBO.
They would buy a few a year and then push them for the Oscar. They always won the short documentary Oscar. So Op-Docs, you know, we sort of we knew that and we were like, hm, can we get into the short Oscar game? It turns out we could and we did.
Yeah. And I just find the cuz I've come into the short Oscar game through friends of mine who have had, you know, documentaries also nominated fiction nominated. But just from seeing the all the FYC screenings and the kind of like machinery behind what it goes into just even getting into the final 15. Can you speak about you know being on the inside of that because I think it's quite opening eye opening to people who don't actually know what actually goes into just getting you know nominated. There's a lot of, you know, bells and whistles that I don't think people realize goes into you know, obviously getting that far.
Yeah. And also the process has changed. So, just to do a quick self promotion, I recently did a Substack where I interviewed Tom Oyer who worked at the academy for almost 20 years. That's just a really informative deep dive into the rules and the process of getting your film reviewed by the academy and then you know eligible to be nominated. So that goes in depth but al so at a high level the first year that Op-Docs went for an Oscar was in 2014. It was a short dock that was already eligible it's called Our Curse. It's incredible film. Made by Polish directors. There was I don't know if anyone remembers that moment when Poland had a plethora of amazing documentary filmmakers before the political winds changed.
But at that time the process was you would do the paperwork of course to make it eligible which this film had already done cuz I think it had won a festival. And then we acquired it for Op-Docs and we hired a publicist and essentially the Oscar publicist had the list of all of the documentary branch voters and their emails. So, you're sort of paying them for access to that list. And then you would set up screenings and invite Oscar voters and nonosscar voters to fill the room to get people aware of the film and seeing it. And then, of course, we had the New York Times megaphone.
So, we published the film on the New York Times to align with certain deadlines and stuff like that to help promote it. But that was really the process. So the cost in 2014 was essentially hiring the publicist, putting on the events. But a few years later, the rules changed. So the way that it works now is if you want to campaign for a short documentary or any other Oscar, you h in order to email the Oscar voters, you have to go through the academy and they charge thousands of dollars. So, it's really changed the game. And I honestly think it's quite unfair, especially for short documentary filmmakers, that you have to pay thousands of dollars to the academy so you can invite people to your screenings and campaign for your film.
I think that chain that change has really turned it into a much more expensive thing. And I have to say, you know, a lot of filmmakers reach out to me for advice on Oscar stuff and advice in general, which I'm always happy to give. And I've heard some really heartbreaking stories of filmmakers who spent tens of thousands of dollars on Oscar campaigns that if they would have come to me earlier, I would have told them to not waste their time. I mean, here's the thing about an Oscar campaign, and this is what I used to say to Op-Docs filmmakers. Just the campaign for the short list is great for your career.
And when you're campaigning just to get on the short list, you don't have to go through well maybe technically you're supposed to, but you don't really have to go through the academy. That really only kicks in once you're shortlisted. But if you're if you do really want to push for the Oscar, I think you should be really clear with yourself about the process and how much money it takes and if it's really worth it. I think the way to make it worth it is if instead of thinking about an Oscar campaign, you think about it as maybe, you know, public facing it's an Oscar campaign because that can be a good way to raise money and get people excited.
But on the back side, it's really an opportunity for you to promote yourself as a director. And because as you're doing these events and inviting people, you're meeting people. And unfortunately in your in life, this is the worst advice, but I have to tell everyone because it's also really important. In life, it's not who you know, it's who knows you. So, as you're trying to make a name for yourself in film, get to know as many people as possible. Of course, directors, film festival programmers, and also people at your own level. You don't always have to be kissing ass up. Just people just as many people as you can in the field.
Try to get to know them and you can use that Oscar campaign as actually a way to meet people because people want to help. The documentary community is really wonderful especially new voices. Everyone wants to pitch in or not everyone but most people want to pitch in and you know bring in new talent. So really use it as an opportunity to network, talk about your work, talk about what you want to do next, figure out who you want to work with, so you can really pursue those relationships. But to think of as an Oscar campaign as purely just about the award, and especially if you're paying for that yourself or out of the pocket of, you know, a few donors is it's it can be a very demoralizing process.
But if you're honest about it having these larger returns on investment besides the award, then I think it can be worth it.
Right. Right. And I think I completely agree with what you said about you know I guess public facing it's obviously you have the campaign for the film but the friends of mine that I know who have done this and I think have got the most out of it is yeah using as a platform just to showcase themselves as filmmakers because it there's so much visibility. It's like you're in the trades, you're doing some are doing like TV interviews, you know, some are like physically campaigning at, you know, schools and, you know, media publications. So, I think it's such a great platform for that. So just before we transition into talking about, I guess, present day you know, film making and and the future.
So, you spent 11 years at Op-Docs NYT. Was it a
Let me just clarify. Sorry. I was at Op-Docs until 2018 and then I became the editorial director for film and television. So, even though I kept working on op some Op-Docs just because some Op-Docs took years to make. Officially in 2018 I transitioned to a new role and that was to produce documentaries based in New York Times reporting and sell them to streamers. So those projects include the 1619 project which was bought by Disney and was on Hulu and won a prime time Emmy for best series. But also feature docs like Time directed by Garrett Bradley, Some Kind of Heaven and Spermworld directed by Lance Oppenheim, Sorry Not Sorry directed by Caroline Suh.
So, I know it's like confusing from the outside, but just to like make that distinction.
Sure. Yeah. And with so when you left in 2024, was it a I guess was it an instant decision to leave or was it something that you thought of for a few years?
I mean again, you know, our lives happen in the context of the greater cultural, economic, political moments, right? And in 2018, that was when there was a gold rush in Hollywood. Netflix and all of the stream, many streamers that honestly don't even exist anymore, but in that moment did had their checkbooks open and were writing big checks to make documentaries. And that's what people say the golden age, that's what they're remembering. 2018, you know, to 2021. There were just there was just so much opportunity to sell projects and essentially especially for a place like the New York Times to sell projects at an early stage, right?
So that's kind of the you're living the dream. You go to Netflix, you pitch something they buy it and you make it. Although it's I definitely have there's a lot more to say on that which I won't get into now but you know in by 2024 the economics had changed around documentary and the economy of developing docs with great directors on super interesting subjects just wasn't there as it had in before. And so as the opportunities really changed into being, you know, streamers really focusing on projects that are mass appeal, so true crime, celebrity, I just those aren't the types of projects that I'm excited to make.
And I, you know, I'd also been at the times for a long time and I was just ready to do something different. And you know it's sometimes in life you're just ready to try new things and have new challenges. So, it was really about just wanting to have a new chapter career-wise, seeing where all these larger forces were going and sort of the writing on the wall that we're living through now with all the consolidation and the cost cutting. It's just it's not as fun as it was, right? Making documentaries with the streamers as it was for a while where they were greenlighting amazing interesting work, right?
And I guess speaking to that of you know cost cutting and new chapters and you know this new I guess taking a leap into the unknown. AI and I find it quite obviously there's you know so much has been said about it especially in the fiction space but I find for me I think AI and its use in documentary for me from what I've seen is actually more interesting to me personally especially when you look at instances where they've used AI I to bring certain talent technically from the dead. They obviously you had and the and I don't know if you know but the Andy Warhol documentary where they cloned his voice for narration.
And obviously they had the similarly with Anthony Bourdain but obviously that had some ethical issues with it. So I guess from your perspective are you seeing any interesting use cases for AI be it generative be it in terms of tools that is I guess helping democratize documentary film making.
I think there's like sort of two pieces of the AI conversation. One is the creative impact of, you know, building B-roll instead of going out and shooting something, creating it versus a in AI or what you were talking about mimicking people's voices. And then there's like AI like making editing like faster, cheaper, easier. I feel like there's like a they're like two different conversations. I mean, I think starting with the creative, you know, working at the Times, it gave me this incredible education into how to think about telling true stories cuz that's something The Times has been doing, you know, for over 180 years.
And it's something that's sort of core to their mission. And you know, it was a really interesting part of my job to sort of be working across these two different disciplines, which is like written journalism for the New York Times and then making these documentaries at Op-Docs and then when you're doing the features and series and how do you know what is truth and what is you know like for example if you're shooting a documentary and you go into someone's house and you straighten the pillows behind them in the shot, whatever. A print reporter would consider that like you can't change anything. So there's I think there's different, you know, there's sort of these different very I think finite rules around capturing the truth that ultimately don't matter.
Like, does it matter if you turn off an air conditioner so that the interview sounds better? I would argue it doesn't because ultimately we're not here. We're here to find whatever the truth is. And truth is a complicated thing. And at the end of the day, having audio that's clear and understandable, I would argue, gets us closer to the truth than like not turning off an air conditioner because you don't want to change the setting. But there's a debate to be had about even just something that granular. And then when it comes to getting into, for like with the Anthony Bourdain example, recreating someone's voice through AI, I think there's two ways of looking at it.
On the one hand, it could get us closer to the truth because then we're able to hear if especially if they're words that were actually said by Andy Warhol and not written by someone else, like to hear his in his voice, you know, speaking in the modality of documentary, something that was only written. I think there's an argument to be made that's totally fine and actually gets us closer to the truth than having an actor read it. But I think it's a really slippery slope. And one of the ways to handle it, something I learned at the times is about thinking about the contract with the audience and is the audience aware that this is being done?
Because I think if you tell people what you're doing and then you let them make your own their own decision, that doesn't detract from the work, it actually adds to it. It makes it more interesting to think about. Me as a someone who watching something with Andy Warhol's AI voice, if I know that going into it, I'm going to have an opinion and I'm going to have thoughts about it. And to me, that like makes the work kind of more interesting and meaty and there's sort of more levels. Someone else might be like, "I hated it. I didn't think it was okay." But like, it's okay for people not to agree.
Like, that's a great debate. Like, let's talk about it. Where I think it really crosses a line is when you're pulling the wool over the audience's eyes and they don't know that what they're seeing is fabricated and manipulated through a series of decisions that they're not even aware being made. And instead, they just think they're getting, you know, sort of an unfiltered. This was audio that was recorded in 1968 or whatever. I do have a problem with that. But I think that, you know, especially with visuals, I mean, and with audio, too, there's ways to signal things aren't exactly what you think they are through the use of filters or illustration.
You know, it's like when we see like archival footage of New York City from 1942 and a documentary that was just made now, like we're not assuming someone went back in time to shoot that, right? We know that somebody else filmed that and then it's being used illustratively in this other work and like we're okay with that. And I think that can also be something that AI footage could be used for if people are aware that this B-roll or whatever it is AI generated and that's being used to like illustrate and flesh out, that's okay. But if you're adding in AI created imagery of New York City in 1942 and the audience doesn't know that, I think that's wrong.
If you're if you're doing something that's contemporary, like let's say you're making a documentary about a family and you use AI to make a scene of the family eating dinner, the audience needs to know that's AI and that's not real and also why that made sense and why that choice was made, which I think can be done intelligently. But I just really feel strongly that the audience needs to be in on it. And it also doesn't have to be in the moment. I mean, Stories We Tell is an example I always bring up. If I don't know if everyone knows that movie, but it's Sarah Polley's documentary about her family and her relationship with her parents, and there's this thread of like Super 8 footage of her mom from like the ' 70s, young, beautiful, and as you're watching it, you think that was like something she had in her basement.
By the end it's revealed that it was made for the film, right? So, I think there's so much creativity and richness that can be added with these, you know, other elements pulled into the palette for making a film, even a true one. But I think it just has to be honest.
Right. Right. And I think yeah, like you said, as long as we're all aware that this is being done, it gives us the agency to make a choice. Cuz even now I like I'll be scrolling on my social media feed and I'm even getting tricked because it's getting too close to reality now. Sometimes you see these like still images of like historical events that happened but the image didn't wasn't taken at the time. And I'm thinking h I now I'm thinking did this actually happen or not? Because it's so like almost photorealistic and now I'm like oh well I feel de deceived if it was like sold as a meme and oh this is just completely an AI almost like re reenactment of what had happened then I would trust whoever created that image a lot more and I think yeah definitely with film making I think yeah like audiences will trust that but just going back to what you said about in print.
For example, if someone went to interview a subject and they were to move the pillow, that would be a complete no. So, how would that also transfer to so you're saying that in terms of video back when you're working for the New York Times that would be okay to do for let's say like a an opark or a commission video it would be okay to move a pillow in the back of an interview with the subject or not so much.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I mean but that again goes to the AI conversation in different mediums. There are sort of different allowances and I mean we have to be really careful about this and this is also why it's so important to know who's making the documentary that you're watching. And to your point about how like you don't tr trust a creator if they're presenting AI images as real, it's like that's what it really goes down to. And you know, as we watch and consume documentaries and all these different platforms from YouTube to Netflix to HBO to Instagram, TikTok, wherever, it's like, who made that image?
Who made that? Who's telling you that story? What are their values? What do they stand for? Who's paying for it? Because when you're getting something from the New York Times, the New York Times is owned by the Sulzberger family. They've owned it forever. They want to own it forever. They're not Jeff Bezos at the Washington Post, which you know, I think everyone knows that story. So, I think now it's really incumbent on audiences to pay a lot of attention on who's telling the story and why they're telling the story and who's paying for that story because in many ways like that's the most important thing because if it's a source that you trust and you know, yeah, they're going to have had to make they're going to have had to make a million decisions in how they present this story.
And there might make some decisions that are really more in service of story than maybe the absolute facts, but at the end of the day, this is the process of making non-fiction stories. Like, and if you don't know who's sort of holding the keys to that, then you as a viewer don't know what you're really getting and how manipulated it was or is.
Right. Right. And I think Yeah. No, 100%. And I think obviously you could you know argue technically that you know film is deception but I think there's a threshold and that there's a limit to that yeah and I just wanted to talk about because I'm also connecting with so many filmmakers now having you know Substacks and I'm always intrigued into learning about the decision to create a Substack as a filmmaker. So, I'd love to know what inspired you to, you know, to dive into Substack and use that as a platform to for your voice.
Well, as I mentioned, I have this background as being a writer and a print journalist. And in fact, I saw my high school teacher recently and he was like, "You've always been such a good writer." I was like, "Really? I have." So it's honestly been something even when you know when I was little I used to write stories and notebooks. So I've always had the writer side to me and I think I just sort of buried it especially the last sort of 15 years. And so coming out of my you know experience professionally of just producing so many docs and that being all-consuming it felt like an interesting moment just to go back to writing as a creative expression because also it's so different from film making.
I always say film making is a team sport right like you need a lot of people but when you're writing you can really do it yourself and then also on Substack you can publish whatever you want whenever you want which is maybe bad it would probably be done editors but whatever so for me it's a creative out outlet you know and people say write about what you know I know a ton about documentary and it's fun to find other people who are interested in it too So that was really the starting point and you know I guess when I started Substack I was also just curious about it as a technology and as a new social platform.
So it's been a really interesting experience on a lot of levels. I would say that it's definitely not a way to make money. I think that just for everyone watching thinking about starting a Substack, like all the numbers you've seen about how much money you can make that Substack puts out there are not accurate. It's really not or maybe I'm just doing it wrong, but I don't know. I feel like it's definitely not something that is financially rewarding. I mean, you can make, you know, a few a little bit of money, but nothing that's like a life-changing. But it's really fun to be part of this creative community, talk to new people, put your thoughts out there, get responses.
So, it's I think it's a wonderful creative outlet for people who enjoy that sort of quick writing, getting feedback, sharing, reading what other people are writing. It's like it's like a fun ecosystem to be in. I mean, I think that I think it would be interesting to start putting films on Substack. I've seen a few people trying it. But I think ultimately the opportunity for filmmakers is to have an audience for your work so that when you do have a film coming out, you have a place to organically talk about it. I mean, I have a project that I'm producing right now, and you know, I'm not I haven't written about it yet on Lingo on Docs, but I definitely plan to, you know, when we're at the right point in the process because ultimately, you know, our work is only as valuable as the audience it has.
So I think the audience building opportunity is like even more valuable than the financial one because you also meet people you know like how we met. I get I do consult, you know, people reach out to me to consult on their projects because I've read my Substack. So, it's a great calling card and especially for producers and directors who really otherwise only have movies which only can come out really every couple years. It's a great thing to do like in the interim to keep to stay in the conversation to keep creating. I mean, I don't care what anyone says. Writing a thousand words is just as creative as anything else.
It's so hard to write no matter what you're writing about and it's just like a good way to keep your brain moist, right?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That was a great action there. No, 100%. And I guess it would be good to know or do so you saying you have this project that you haven't written about, but your subst where do you see yourself taking it? Do you have goals for the rest of the year? Do you have like big posts coming up? Do you have anything upcoming that you're looking to super excited about?
Yeah, well, I'm definitely in the process of figuring out how to do more. Actually had a call this morning with someone who reached out to me about, you know, taking me on kind of as a client to grow my business with the Substack. And I feel like there is a lot of opportunity for films and creating more audience. So, right now my goals are to keep try to publish something once a week, which is a big is a high that's a big reach for me. Because I also have other projects and I'm also a mom. So, you know, just having the time to do all of this is a struggle, but at the end of the day, I think it's a really important project for me creatively and for my career.
So, I'm definitely going to keep pushing. I'm curious to see more in terms of the data around my video posts versus my written posts and which get more engagement. I recently set up a YouTube page. Lingo on Docs is now on YouTube. I have two videos up there. But exploring that because I put a few clips on Instagram reels and they just got thousands and thousands of views and on Substack it's really hard to get the kind of numbers as quickly. Like the numbers definitely build on Substack which is also really interesting but there's some immediacy to the numbers you can get on platforms that just like have more people.
So I'm really trying to figure out what's a good strategy to sort of expand the audience in terms of numbers, but then to also really have content on Substack that is really engaging and that will keep people reading and then hopefully becoming paid subscribers and figuring out, you know, what is the sweet spot. I definitely one piece of intel I'll share is my posts that are simply about a movie like people are less excited about than posts that are more about I mean still talking to filmmakers but more about strategy and like the future and you know like I wrote a two-parter on Sundance that did really well.
So it feels like there's an appetite for having more conversations about the making of the industry, all of that than there are really drilling down into specific films, which I think is super interesting.
You know, I didn't there's so much stuff about, you know, documentary film making that even though I did study it partly at university just, you know, learning from someone who's in the know now about how documentaries are being made now, I think has been has been fascinating. So, I'm super excited to see yeah, what your next post, what the rest of the year looks like for you in terms of your substack. And yeah, this has been a great dive to talk about documentary film making truth you know technology and obviously filmmakers on Substack like the both of us. So Kathleen, in terms of where people should seek you out, obviously you have your Substack, but is there any other place people should, you know, try and reach out and find you?
Yeah, definitely my Substack, Lingo on Docs, is the best place to find me. I mean, I'm also on Instagram and like I said, I just started a YouTube channel, so you can definitely hit me up in those two places as well. But subscribe to Lingo on Docs. I will appreciate it forever and I really appreciate being on this podcast and having this conversation. It was really smart and fun and I'm really thrilled that I got to be here today and chat with you.
Yes. And we've been absolutely thrilled to have you on and yeah guys, so this is the end of our second episode. Another documentary one.